Welcome to Omgili,
Omgili ( Oh My God I Love It ;) is a search engine for discussions. With Omgili you can find answers and solutions, debates, discussions, personal experiences, opinions and more... To learn more about Omgili click here.
This is a complete preview of the discussion as it was indexed by Omgili crawlers. Use this preview if the original discussion is unavailable.
Click here to view the original discussion.
[http://idolforums.com/index.php?s...]
Click here to search for discussions with Omgili discussions search engine.
 |
Idol Tour Review :: Katharine Off-Topic idolforums.com
Quote: Talk about fixing what was broken.
In previous outings, the annual American Idol tour featured the season’s top 10 contestants performing a large amount of group numbers.
Anyone who has ever watched the TV show can attest to a simple fact: The group numbers suck.
Every year, there are a few contestants who display no noticeable dancing ability.
Others can’t harmonize to save their lives.
It doesn’t help that the group numbers feature the kind of imaginative choreography that you usually find on Brady Bunch reruns.
This year, the tour producers made the wise move of eliminating virtually all group numbers.
There were only two spots featuring the ensemble during the tour’s opening night on Tuesday at Jobing.com Arena.
Winner David Cook did a five-song set;
Runner-up David Archuleta got four tunes and the remaining cast members each got three.
That meant the show moved along at a fairly lively pace and some performers got to display more personality than they showed on screen.
The show ran nearly two-and-a-half hours (with an intermission), but felt shorter.
The concert worked like a countdown, with the No.
10 ranked finalist going first.
Good thing it was one-named Chikezie, who worked the large stage like a pro.
He benefited from the format, opening with a growling rendition of Donny Hathaway’s “I Believe to My Soul.” It was the perfect way to start the night, as he quickly sailed through Usher’s “Caught Up” and a terrific version of John Legend’s “So High” that showcased an awesome falsetto.
Unfortunately, the occasional weakness of the show’s structure was evident once finalist No.
9 entered. Ramiele Malubay was dressed like an exile from a Michael Jackson video, as she sported black patent leather boots, tight black pants and black wrist cuffs.
It was oddly appropriate, because she sang the Jackson 5’s “I Want You Back” in bland karaoke fashion.
She attempted some choreographed steps with two backing singers, but never appeared entirely comfortable.
She also tended to move away from the mic while singing, which didn’t help her voice project through the crowded arena.
If Chikezie was like a partygoer who leaves too soon;
Ramiele was a dinner guest who won’t depart until two hours after dessert is served.
Fortunately, most of the Idols had more to offer.
Aussie Michael Johns came off as capable but bland, with a fondness for arena–rock clichés – did he have to pump his fist in the air so much?
Still, the audience loved him.
Kristy Lee Cook, who didn’t make much of an impression on TV, thrived in concert, as she offered a sassy, hip-wriggling presentation that would go over big with a Nashville crowd.
She repeated her Idol trademark of Lee Greenwood’s “God Bless the USA” and dedicated it to any veterans in the house.
Considering the huge number of adolescents in the arena, one guesses that veterans made up a very small part of the crowd.
Tattooed Carly Smithson opened with a loud and powerful take on Evanescence's “Bring Me to Life.” She is prettier than she appears on TV, and smaller, too.
However, one imagines her lungs must take up a good portion of her body due to the sheer power she displayed.
She closed with a killer version of the Cyndi Lauper favorite “I Drove All Night” that chugged along at a hypnotic pace.
The big news for the Valley was the return of Phoenix native Brooke White, who finished fifth on the show.
The audience roared its approval and greeted her with a standing ovation.
Sitting barefoot at the piano, she earned the honors with a soulful “Let It Be” that inspired goose bumps.
White looked gorgeous and her personality was infectious: “It’s good to be home!” she enthused, and you could tell that she meant it.
She picked up the guitar for Feist's whimsical "1, 2, 3, 4," then closed with a glowing (no pun intended) version of Coldplay’s “Yellow.” She may never become a huge star, but White’s joyful integrity and musical smarts should guarantee her a solid career in the Melissa Manchester/Carole King mode.
After an intermission, dreadlocked Jason Castro charmed his way through a ukulele-driven “Over the Rainbow,” an inspired interpretation of Gnarls Barkley's “Crazy” and the hazy mellowness of “Daydream.” He is so unslick and well-meaning, it is hard not to like him.
On the other hand, every move Syesha Mercado made appeared to be choreographed down to her last hand gesture.
That’s not a knock;
The contrast between her Vegas-ready style and Castro’s coffeehouse charms simply jumped out due to being placed back-to-back in the show.
She closed with Beyonce’s “Listen” and turned the tune into a personal mantra that successfully whipped the crowd up.
If she exited to cheers, things hit ear-piercing levels when David Archuleta hit the stage.
I always rooted for the kid on the show;
On stage, he’s equally impressive.
He opened at the piano with Robbie Williams’ “Angels” and the purity and range of his voice was breathtaking.
Then he took the dark angst of OneRepublic's “Apologize” to illustrate how versatile his voice is and how it can be placed in different settings.
Strangely, the only weak spot was the closer: Josh Groban’s “When You Say You Love Me” is the kind of drippy song that he needs to stay away from, because he is capable of so much more.
He also needs a new fashion coordinator: The shiny black slacks – were they leather?
– and a jacket lined with glittery piping made him look ready for a gig on a cruise ship.
The screams were split pretty evenly between David A.
And David C., who immediately followed.
Cook can come off as cocky on stage;
Constantly exerting the crowd to get up by waving his arms seemed a bit bold for someone who couldn’t have filled a bar in Glendale last year, much less an arena.
But then Cook discussed a sibling who is suffering from cancer: “My brother’s tumor has stopped growing!” he happily told the crowd, and it was hard not to be touched.
His set was uneven, though his spooky Michael Jackson-by-way-of-Chris Cornell version of “Billie Jean” sure was hard to beat.
For the encore, all 10 vocalists were on stage, marching back and forth across the stage while singing Rihanna's "Don't Stop the Music." Brooke and Jason both seemed a bit sheepish;
David C. grinned happily and David A.
Looked up at him like a proud little brother.
Hey, if you have to throw a group number in there for a closer, this wasn't a bad way to end a fun night.
It's a little long but I tried to sum things up if you didn't feel like reading.
This post has been edited by McPheever20: Jul 2nd 2008, 7:24 PM
|
|
I'm sorry where does it say Brooke stole the show?
To me it seemed they had rave reviews for half of the top 10
|
|
Most of them got good reviews but I do agree that Brooke got the best one.
Yay for Carly!
Be strong Bright//Set By Me//
Current Fav Artists:Mariah C.,Gavin D.,Sara Bareilles,Jason Mraz,Danity Kane,Paramore,J.Morrison
|
|
|
I love Brooke but that sounds like a hometown paper?
|
|
|
Lol wow.
|
|
|
Quote:
lol wow.
Cometh to thy trim.
These walls
That they put up
To hold us back
Will fall down
It's a revolution
It's how we'll become
Who we're
Supposed to be
|
|
Quote:
I'm sorry where does it say Brooke stole the show?
To me it seemed they had rave reviews for half of the top 10
She got a full standing ovation and her performance inspired goosebumps?
He had at least one critique about every set, including David A and David C's, except Brooke's.
Plus, getting a full standing ovation at an arena when most fans are there to see the winner and the runner-up is usually considered the big 'high light' of the show.
|
|
Quote:
She got a full standing ovation and her performance inspired goosebumps?
He had at least one critique about every set, including David A and David C's, except Brooke's.
Plus, getting a full standing ovation at an arena when most fans are there to see the winner and the runner-up is usually considered the big 'high light' of the show.
I think you forgot the most important part.
It's her HOME.TOWN.
I don't see anything negative in Chikezes or Carlys, and theirs was the first two i looked at.
|
|
Quote:
I think you forgot the most important part.
It's her HOME.TOWN.
So?
Perhaps I'm missing the part where I said she's going to steal every single show on this tour.
She still stole this one, which is what I initially said, regardless of whether it was her HOME.TOWN or not.
This post has been edited by McPheever20: Jul 2nd 2008, 8:24 PM
|
|
Quote:
So? Perhaps I'm missing the part where I said she's going to steal every single show on this tour.
She still stole this one, which is what I initially said, regardless of whether it was her HOME.TOWN or not.
I think you're missing the most glaringly obvious part.
Which is that its her hometown, they're going to give her a favourable review regardless.
As the tour progresses read all the reviews from each contestants hometown and which one they favour.
|
|
Quote:
I think you're missing the most glaringly obvious part.
No actually, I'm not.
You are. I know it's her hometown and I know the audience is going to react differently towards her performance, but I was never talking about that.
I just simply stated the fact that she stole this show, which she did, regardless of where it was.
Period. No buts.
|
|
|
Just..wow.
|
|
Quote:
No actually, I'm not.
You are. I know it's her hometown and I know the audience is going to react differently towards her performance, but I was never talking about that.
I just simply stated the fact that she stole this show, which she did, regardless of where it was.
Period. No buts.
LOL.
Yeah you're right, I'm totally missing the point thats why people are siding with me in this thread 100%.
Look, I like Brooke, but to think that a) that reviewer wasn't favourable to anyone else and the hometown bias writing isn't going to be there is just...
|
|
Actually the way I read that , Krusty gets as good a writeup as anyone.
Sounds to me like Chikeze, Kristy, Carly and Brooke all "stole the show".
One little critique to the reviewer, a great deal of those adolecents in the audience come to the Idol show with their parents.
Many of whom may have been veterans.
|
|
Quote:
LOL. Yeah you're right, I'm totally missing the point thats why people are siding with me in this thread 100%.
Look, I like Brooke, but to think that a) that reviewer wasn't favourable to anyone else and the hometown bias writing isn't going to be there is just...
I know why the reviewer was favourable for Brooke.
I know why she got a standing ovation.
I know it's her hometown.
But that's not even my point.
I said she stole the show, which she did.
Why is that concept so hard to grasp?
Of course the people in her hometown are going to like her better, and of course the reviews aren't exactly going to tear her apart, and of course it's to be expected but that's...not...my...point?
I don't get why it's so hard to..understand?
Would it make you feel better if I said Brooke stole the first Idol show in her hometown?
What difference does it make?
She still did.
This post has been edited by McPheever20: Jul 2nd 2008, 8:39 PM
|
|
...because she didn't steal the show.
It wasn't applied or even outright said in the review.
The only one that came to that conclusion was you.
|
|
One quick question Cesar, were you there?
Or are you only basing this on just one review?
|
|
Quote:
...because she didn't steal the show.
It wasn't applied or even outright said in the review.
The only one that came to that conclusion was you.
And how did YOU come to that conclusion?
|
|
|
Quote:
And how did YOU come to that conclusion?
by listening to the show, and reading other reviews?
|
|
Quote:
by listening to the show, and reading other reviews?
Except I listened to the show too and that' clearly not the conclusion I came up with.
Different strokes, different folks.
I made the thread so obviously, I'm going to post MY views and the conclusion I came up with by reading this and three other reviews.
You don't havee to agree though, naturally.
|
|
|
|